Connect with us

Explainers

Maratha Kranti Morcha: Why are Marathas demanding Reservation?

Arti Ghargi

Published

on

Maratha

It was in the year 1993 when the demand to include Marathas in reservation categories was first raised.

 

The Maratha Quota stir hit Mumbai on Wednesday. The organizers of the Maratha Kranti Morcha declared a Mumbai Bandh. The streets of Mumbai were flooded with the Maratha Protestors. Though, the Bandh has been called off, the protest by Maratha community has already created ripples. But why the Maratha community-one of the electorally powerful community in Maharashtra is protesting?

The main goal of the Maratha quota stir is to secure a certain percentage of reservation in Education and Government Jobs. Broadly, the Maratha Quota agitation can be identified with Patidar reservation demand. Like Patidar community, Maratha community holds constitutes a significant percentage of Maharashtra’s population and is electorally significant. The dominance of Marathas in Maharashtrian politics can be understood by the sheer number of Chief Ministers from the community. Right from Maharashtra’s first Chief Minister Yashvantrao Chavhan to Prithviraj Chavan, as many as 11 Chief Ministers were from the Maratha community. The powerful community stands 32% of the entire population of Maharashtra and dominates 80% of the total 288 assembly seats in the state.

Maratha

Chief Ministers of Maharashtra from Maratha Community

Maratha Reservation demand:

The demand for reservation to Maratha community is not recently founded. Though it revived again on a massive scale after Kopardi gang-rape case, the demand has been there for over two decades. It was in 1993 when the demand to include Marathas in reservation categories was raised. In the 1990s, the National Front government led by V. P. Singh implemented the Mandal Commission recommendations.

The Mandal Commission, or the Socially Backward Classes Commission set up in the 1980s was tasked with identifying the “socially or educationally backward classes” of India. The commission in its study found out that the Other Backward Castes comprise 52% of India’s population. The commission also recommended that the OBCs be given 27% reservation in government jobs. The report was pushed under the sheets due to the political ramification, however, the V. P. Singh government revived it.

Maratha

Image Source: Web

As the implementation of the recommendations came into effect, the then Maharashtra government added Kunbi community in the OBC category but omitted the Maratha. This did not go down well with the Maratha community which contested that Marathas and Kunbis are the same.

In December 2009, 18 Maratha organizations came under umbrella banner of the Maratha Aarakshan Sangharsh Samiti (MASS). The organization led many protests stoking caste politics in the state. It was in 2014 when Congress-NCP government was battling Anti-incumbency, the Maharashtra government gave in to demands of Maratha community. The then Congress-NCP government created a separate category called Educationally and Socially Backward Category (ESBC) for Marathas and granted 16% reservation. However, Bombay High Court struck the order down.

 

Are Marathas really Backward?

The term “Backward” here stands as a key contention. Backwards can be defined as those set of people or communities that are socially, educationally and economically disadvantaged. Does the Maratha community fit on these parameters? The answer is both yes and no. The Maratha community similar to Patels in Gujrat comes under Kshatriya Varna. Historically, the community is regarded as a warrior community but the later generations settled in agriculture and the community came to be known as the agriculturist. Thus, unlike other communities, Dalits for example, they do not have any social stigma attached to them.

The Marathas has enough representation in lower level government jobs but is still underrepresented in Class-I jobs in engineering, medicine, etc. Thus, the educational status of the overall community should be under scrutiny.

Maratha

Image Source: Web

The Marathas in Western Maharashtra is considered politically influential and wealthy community. This is due to the growth of co-operative sectors in the region. Western Maharashtra has a huge share in state’s co-operative banks, co-operative sugar factories, co-operative milk industry, etc. The local Marathas thus emerged as the wealthy and prestigious community. The Marathas from Western Maharashtra also became a dominant force in state’s politics.

However, this does not imply that every Maratha has the economically strong background. There is a vast majority of Marathas that resides in Marathwada, Vidarbha and Khandesh which has seen the worst track record in farmer’s suicide.  The area has been one of the worst drought-hit areas. The increasing debt, lack of agricultural facilities, low yield has made the occupation difficult for the Marathas.

Maratha

Maratha Kranti Morcha (Silent March) in 2017

However, in 2003-04, National Commission for Backward Classes didn’t approve OBC status for Marathas. Even in 2008, the Maharashtra State Backward Class Commission had declared Marathas economically and politically a forward caste. However, with OBC already having 27% of reservation, the total amount of reservation has gone up to 49%. Granting reservation to  Marathas will violate Supreme Court ruling putting 50% cap on the reservation. This was also the very reason why the Bombay High Court had struck it down.

However, Tamil Nadu has set an example in this context. The state has 69% reservation. Following Tamil Nadu’s step, Maharashtra first has to prove that more than 50% of the state’s population is backward and then it can pass an act.

Explainers

Why the SC appointed AK Patnaik to head the investigation in Alok Verma case?

Arti Ghargi

Published

on

patnaik

Justice Patnaik was a part of a two-judge bench formed in March 2016 for the 2G spectrum case.

 

The high voltage drama in India’s premier investigating agency Central Bureau of Agency got a sane turn with Supreme Court ordering a probe into the matter. The CBI bloodbath that happened post-midnight on Tuesday saw the two topmost officials being removed from their posts. The warring officers i.e. CBI Director Alok Verma and Special Director Rakesh Asthana were sent on “forced leave” while the entire team of officials probing corruption case against Asthana was transferred overnight. The breakneck reaction by the government thus raised questions whether there was any cover-up.

Image Source: Web

However, CBI Director Alok Verma moved to the Supreme Court challenging his removal and demanded an urgent hearing in the matter. The Supreme Court today took up the matter for hearing and ordered a probe into the matter under the supervision of retired Supreme Court Judge AK Patnaik. It has also ordered that the probe must be completed within 10 days and the report to be submitted to the apex court during the next hearing on November 12. The court has also prevented the interim director of the CBI Nageshwar Rao from taking important decisions in policy matters.

CBI

CBI Director Alok Verma and Special Director Rakesh Asthana

While there has been no immediate relief for Alok Verma, the silver lining is a probe has been initiated in the matter. What is more interesting is the retired Supreme Court judge AK Patnaik will be monitoring the probe.

Who is AK Patnaik?

AK Patnaik will be heading the committee investigating allegations of corruption against CBI chief Alok Verma. The former Supreme Court judge was born on June 3, 1949. He graduated in Political Science from Delhi University and studied Law from Cuttack. Patnaik became a member of the Odisha Bar Association in 1974. About 20 years after stepping in the law profession, he became an additional judge in Odisha High Court in 1994. However, he was soon sent to the Guwahati High Court where he became a permanent judge the very next year. He worked there for seven years before being sent to his home state in 2002.

Image Source: Web

Subsequently, in March 2005, Justice Patnaik was made the Chief Justice of Chhattisgarh High Court. In October the same year, he was appointed Chief Justice of Madhya Pradesh High Court. The then Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Justice Ramesh Chandra Lahoti had praised his work as the Chief Justice of the Chhattisgarh High Court. In November 2009, he was made the judge of the Supreme Court. Five years later Justice Patnaik retired in June 2014. The most discussed case in Justice Patnaik is Justice Soumitra Sen’s case.

 

What is Soumitra Sen case?

Justice Soumitra Sen was charged with misappropriation of money and misrepresenting facts. Justice Patnaik was a part of the three-member committee of judges set up to investigate the allegations. In its report, this committee accused Justice Sen of “wrongful behaviour”. There were allegations on Sen of misusing nearly Rs 33 lakhs and being the court receiver when a legal case in dispute between the Steel Authority of India and the Shipping Authority of India was ongoing.

patnaik

Image Source: Web

The Chief Justice of India and the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha had created committees to investigate the allegations. The committee reports said that Soumitra Sen was the first receiver when he was a lawyer and later as a judge. During his tenure as a judge, he continued withdrawing cash and issuing a check from the same bank account in which he had received money as a lawyer. After the report came out CPM leader Sitaram Yechury presented a proposal in the Rajya Sabha to remove Soumitra Sen. The proposal was passed by the Upper House with a majority.

It was for the first time in India’s history that such a resolution was passed against a High Court judge. This proposal was to be taken up by Lok Sabha, but before that, Soumitra Sen resigned.

 

2G, Spot Fixing case:

Though Soumitra Sen case was the highlight of the career of AK Patnaik, he has also handled other high stake cases including the 2G scam case which led the undoing of UPA government and Spot Fixing case. Justice Patnaik was a part of a two-judge bench formed in March 2016 for the 2G spectrum case. Apart from this, Justice Patnaik was also included in the Supreme Court bench that heard the plea demanding an alternate provision to NOTA and spot-fixing in the IPL.

patnaik

Image Source: Web

After retirement, Justice Patnaik was proposed to be made the President of the Odisha State Human Rights Commission, but he refused. Justice Patnaik was also involved in a bench, which gave the verdict that if a legislator or MP is convicted in a criminal case, he/she will not be able to contest elections for six years.

Among the law fraternity, he is regarded as a judge with high integrity and stickler of discipline. This probably explains why CJI Ranjan Gogoi appointed him to head the investigation which will have a significant impact on the prestige of India’s premier investigative agency.

 

Continue Reading

Explainers

Who are the five people arrested in Bhima Koregaon violence case?

Arti Ghargi

Published

on

activists

The trail leading to Bhima-Koregaon violence probe also revealed an alleged Maoist plot of Rajiv Gandhi-style assassination of PM Modi.

In a continuation of a crackdown on Elgar Parishad, a public meeting held at Pune a day prior to the Bhima-Koregaon violence that prompted the violent Maharashtra Bandh, the Pune police have arrested five activists on Tuesday. The police claimed that the five activists have a connection with the banned Communist Party of India (Maoist).

The five lawyers/activists namely, Sudha BharadwajArun Ferreira, Vernon Gonsalves, Gautam Navlakha and revolutionary writer P Varavara Rao were arrested in a trail of multi-city raids that began on Tuesday morning.  These activists were taken into custody from Faridabad, Thane, Mumbai, Delhi and Hyderabad, respectively. The Joint CP of Pune Shivaji Bodhke said that the police have made the arrests on the basis of “incriminating evidence collected during the investigation and documents recovered from the five activists arrested on June 6.”

Post Bhima-Koregaon violence, the police action were prompted by two FIRs filed in January this year against Gujarat MLA Jignesh Mewani and Student Leader Umar Khalid and some other members for provocative statements at Elgar Parishad. According to the police, the statement made led to the incitement of violence. When the probe progressed, the police found that some of the members were in touch with the banned CPI(Maoist).  This trail led to the June 6 raids and arrests of Sudhir Dhawale- editor of Marathi magazine ‘Vidrohi’ (rebel), Lawyer Surendra Gadling, Nagpur University Professor Shoma Sena, former PMRD fellow Mahesh Raut and Rona Wilson- allegedly a close aide of arrested JNU professor GN Saibaba. Currently, all the arrested are in Yerwada jail. The trail also revealed an alleged Maoist plot of Rajiv Gandhi-style assassination of PM Modi.

According to the police, the names of all the five arrested early Tuesday morning figured during the investigation of the above-arrested people. Here is the background of the arrested people.

Sudha Bharadwaj:

A familiar face for the journalists, lawyers and activists who have worked in Chhattisgarh, Sudha Bharadwaj is a human rights lawyer. She has spent nearly 30 years in Chhattisgarh fighting the cases of Dalits, farmers, labourers and tribals against the land acquisition. Bharadwaj is also associated with the People’s Union of Civil Liberties (PUCL) as a national secretary. Apart from PUCL, she has been associated with Chhattisgarh Mukti Morcha, which advocated the protection of the cultural identity of the state and rights of workers and peasants.

However, recently she came under the fire allegedly for sympathizing with Maoists and their methods of violent insurgencies. There were claims that she allegedly received money from them. However, Bharadwaj has denied these allegations. Though, she has time and again said that she had appeared for Adivasis in fake encounter cases and cases against Human Rights activists, she has acted with professional integrity and courage.

Arun Ferreira:

Arun Ferreira was arrested from his Thane residence on Tuesday. A Mumbai based human rights activist-lawyer, Ferreira has been arrested before as well in connection with the Naxalites. In 2007, he was taken into custody on the charges of being a Naxal operative; which were dropped later and he was acquitted. As many as 11 cases were registered against him in the subsequent four years under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, the Arms Act and even sedition. After the acquittal in 2011, he was arrested again. However, he was granted bail soon.

After getting out of jail, Ferreira received his degree from Siddharth Law college and became a practising lawyer since December 2016. He also became a part of the ‘Indian Association of People’s Lawyer and the Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights.

Vernon Gonsalves:

Vernon Gonsalves was arrested from Mumbai. Before the arrest, he used to work as a professor of Business Organization at a prominent Mumbai College. The security agencies labelled him as an ex-central committee member and former secretary of Maharashtra State Rajya Committee of Naxalites outfits. He was arrested in 2007 but was convicted in June 2013 under various sections of Unlawful Activities (Preventions) Act and Arms Act. Though he was charged in 20 cases, he was declared not guilty in 17 cases as the prosecution couldn’t furnish any evidence against him.

However, as he had already served the prison period sentenced to him, he was released immediately.

Gautam Navlakha:

Gautam Navlakha was arrested from Delhi. A very well-known journalist, Navlakha has also served as consultant editor at Economic and Political Weekly. Apart from journalism, he was involved in activism for the civil and human right. He was also actively involved with People’s Union for Democratic Right.

As a journalist and writer, he has visited the troubled state of Kashmir many times and written about the human right violation incidents. He was a convenor of International People’s Tribunal on Human Rights and Justice in Kashmir. He was charged with Section 144 for unlawful assembly with an intent to disrupt the peace.

P Varavara Rao:

P Varavara Rao was arrested from his Hyderabad Residence. The renowned poet, journalist, literary critic, and public speaker from Telangana is considered one of the best Marxist critics in Telugu literature. He founded Srujana (creation), a forum for modern literature in Telugu in 1966. He was one of the founders of Viplava Rachayitala Sangam (Revolutionary Writers’ Association), popularly known by its acronym Virasam.  The Virasam allegedly supports and propagates Naxalite ideology and practice.

In 1973, he was arrested by the Andhra Pradesh police under the Maintenance of Internal Security Act (MISA). However, he was released after a month and a half. In 1974, he along with 41 others were arrested in a conspiracy case, known as Secunderabad Conspiracy Case. He was acquitted in February 1989, after 15 years of prolonged and tiresome trial.  He was also arrested during the emergency.

In 2001, the then Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) Peoples War announced the names of Varavara Rao and Gaddar as its emissaries to work out modalities for the proposed peace talks with Telugu Desam Party govt. in Andhra Pradesh.

Continue Reading

Explainers

This powerful speech by Lokmanya Tilak reminds us why “Self-Rule” important

Arti Ghargi

Published

on

Tilak

“Freedom is my birthright. So long as it is awake within me, I am not old,” said Lokmanya Tilak.

 

“Swarajya is my birth-right and I shall have it!” roared Bal Gangadhar Tilak as he emerged from the prison in present-day Mumbai. India found a new slogan which paved the way for India’s Independence struggle and Tilak became the first Lokmanya leader of it. While for the most part of his contribution to Indian Freedom Struggle, he advocated radical approach, however, later in his last years he took up the task of taking the message of Swarajya to rural India. On the lines of Swarajya (Self-Rule) Tilak advocated a Home Rule (Self-governance) for India. He launched Home Rule League in April 1916 to work in Maharashtra (primarily in Bombay Presidency), Karnataka, the Central Provinces and Berar. The objectives of Tilak’s League were: 1) Establishment of self-government for India in British Empire and 2) Working for national education and social and political reforms.

The Membership for the Home Rule League skyrocketed from 1000 in November 1916 to 14,000 in April 1917 and to 32,000 in 1918. This was primarily due to the fiery speeches delivered by Tilak. The Home Rule League organized discussions and lectures and set up reading rooms. It distributed newspapers and pamphlets in English and vernacular languages, educating people about objectives of the movement. Members of the league were powerful orators and petitions of thousands of Indians were submitted to the British authorities.

Tilak

Image Source: Web

The Home Rule League was inspired by Irish Home Rule movements. While Tilak focused on Western Parts of India, Irish Theosophical leader Annie Besant helped set up Home Rule League in the different parts of the country. She herself was very active in Madras Presidency. Though the Home Rule Movements of Tilak and Besant functioned separately, they worked in close cooperation with each other. The fiery speech by Bal Gangadhar Tilak soon gave massive popularity to the league.

Here’s one of the most popular speech by Bal Gangadhar Tilak on the first anniversary of the formation of the Home Rule League, in 1917, at Nasik.

“I am young in spirit. Even if my body has grown old, the young spirit inside me is still alive. Whatever I am saying today is deeply felt by this young spirit inside me. The body can wilt, it can decrepit or even perish but the soul residing in the body is forever young. Similarly, if our Home Rule activities slow down, the freedom of our inner spirit cannot sustain and no longer will it be indestructible. Then, we ourselves will start believing that we are slaves.

“Freedom is my birthright. I will not be old as long as it is alive within me. This feeling of freedom, no weapon can cut this, no fire can burn it, no water can drown it and no wind can blow it. We are asking for home rule and we will get it. The science of politics teaches us that we cannot achieve through Slavery what we can through Home Rule. The political progress is the pillar of a nation. I want to invoke your soul that yearns for freedom which will only happen through the political progress.”

“I want to destroy this superstition of slavery that has blinded your spirit. This superstition is the reason why you are being let down by ignorant, conniving and selfish people. There are two sides to the science of politics. While one is celestial, another is demonic. The slavery of any nation is the demonic side. There cannot be a moral justification for this. A nation which might justify this is sinful in the sight of God. Some bravely oppose this demonic side of oppression while some who cannot never be able to declare what is harmful to them.

Tilak

Image Source: Web

“These people are capable of giving political and religious teaching, but they do not educate the common people about it.  Religious and political teachings are not separate, though they appear to be so on account of foreign rule. All philosophies are included in the science of politics.”

“Who doesn’t understand the meaning of home rule? Who doesn’t desire it? If I enter your house as a guest, reside there forever and if I don’t pay heed when you oppose; would you like it? According to some people we don’t have the right to home rule. The British are ruling over us for the past century and they say we are not fit for home rule.”

Tilak

Image Source: Web

“If the century of British Rule hasn’t been able to make us competent enough for Home Rule, then we will make ourselves fit for it. They find it shameful that we are making efforts to save our country. On the other hand, England itself is trying to protect the small state of Belgium with India’s help; isn’t that shameful for them? Those who find a selfish motive behind our demands or Home Rule can even find fault in the all-merciful God.”

“We all must save the soul of our nation from this custody of foreign rule. We have to toil for it but it is our birthright to protect our nation. The Congress has passed this home rule resolution.”

“Some selfish interests oppose India’s demand for Home Rule in practical politics on the pretext of several issues ridding our country. One such issue is illiteracy. But together we all can eradicate it. Remember, such issues can only be solved with co-operation. It would be sufficient for us that even the illiterate in our country have a dire desire for Swaraj, let it be the strength of all. Those who can easily complete their work can be illiterate but are not foolish. They can be as intelligent as any literate person. Literacy cannot be the parameter for intelligence.”

Tilak

Image Source: Web

“It is not that difficult to attain Swaraj. Thus, illiteracy can never be the obstacle in the way. Our uneducated brethren are equally important for this country’s Home Rule. They have equal rights.”

“The circumstances change in no time. Today, only once voice echoes, ‘Now or Never’. Therefore, we must take advantage of this opportunity given to us by God and should put our maximum efforts in the struggle for Home Rule. Turn not back, and confidently leave the ultimate issue to the benevolence of the Almighty.”

Continue Reading

Popular Stories

Copyright © 2018 Theo Connect Pvt. Ltd.