The Wire alleged that India Foundation has top ministers of the present government in its Board of Directors which creates ‘Conflict of Interest’.
After the investigative report on Amit Shah’s Son Jay Shah’s company, The Wire.in has now published another investigative article on National Security Adviser Ajit Doval’s son Shaurya Doval.
The exclusive article written by Swati Chaturvedi alleges that Shourya Doval’s India Foundation has “Conflict of interest.”
The article claims that India Foundation which has been “producing monographs on themes like radical Islam in Kerala and the ‘forced conversion’ of adivasis”, saw meteoric rise after Narendra Modi came to power.
The Wire alleged that India Foundation has top ministers of the present government in its Board of Directors. These Top ministers are Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, Commerce and Industry Minister Suresh Prabhu, and two Ministers of State – Jayant Sinha of Civil Aviation Ministry and MJ Akbar of External Affairs Ministry.
However, the article states conflict of interest comes into the picture with the fact that Shourya Doval is a partner at Gemini Financial Services. The firm helps to carry out transactions and capital flows between the OECD and the emerging Asian nations. The report also alleges that this firm has opaque financial dealings.
Here are the highlights from The Wire report:
- Run by the younger Doval and BJP national general secretary Ram Madhav Varanasi, the India Foundation lists among its directors defence minister Nirmala Sitharaman and commerce and industry minister Suresh Prabhu, and two ministers of state – Jayant Sinha (civil aviation) and M.J. Akbar (external affairs).
- As a trust, the foundation is not obliged to make public its balance sheet or financials. Despite the presence of ministers on its board of directors, it refuses to part with any information about its source of revenue.
- The Wire when asked about the source of the foundation’s revenue was: “Conferences, Advertisement, Journal.” He did not answer questions about the origins of this revenue or explain how the India Foundation, which he said was registered as a trust, financed its day-to-day operations, including the rent for its posh premises on Hailey Road in Lutyens’ Delhi, and salaries for its staff.
- Foreign defence and aviation companies like Boeing and the Israeli firm Magal, for instance, as well as foreign banks like DBS, and many private Indian companies are listed as sponsors, though the nature of this sponsorship – how much was paid and to whom, the India Foundation or a ‘partner’ – is not known.
- Doval, who earlier ran the private equity firm Zeus Capital, merged his company to form Gemini Financial Services in 2016. GFS’s chairman is Prince Mishaal Bin Abdullah Bin Turki Bin Abdullaziz Al-Saud, a member of the Saudi ruling family and son of Prince Abdullah bin Turki bin Abdulaziz Al-Saud.
- Given India Foundation’s status as a trust – i.e. a non-governmental organisation – its use of foreign contributions is regulated by the Foreign Contributions Regulation Act (FCRA). The Wire asked Shaurya Doval for details of the India Foundation’s FCRA application and whether it had received any foreign money through the “prior permission” route on the assumption the FCRA database is incomplete. But he did not answer.
- The Wire asked the prime minister’s principal secretary, Nripendra Misra, if he and Modi had taken note of the potential conflict of interest of the directors who double up as ministers and the fact that Shaurya Doval’s father is a top official in the PMO whose remit may include being part of deliberations that concern decisions involving companies that may have sponsored India Foundation events. Again, no answer was forthcoming.
How Kulbhushan Jadhav’s mother saved him from Pakistan’s crooked plot
As American Fiction writer and Blogger N. K. Jemisin had put it “There is no greater warrior than a mother protecting her child”. Today, India can’t stop talking about one such warrior mother who saved her child from giving out a false confession.
Back when Pakistan government finally agreed to give the visa to Kulbhushan Jadhav’s wife, India also pressed for the issuance of a visa to Kulbhushan’s mother as well. After months of application-rejection play up Pakistan issued a visa to Kulbhushan’s wife and mother. While a ray of hope shone in the lives of Kulbhushan’s family members; Pakistan did not miss out on the opportunity to portray this as “Humanitarian” approach. Little did anyone know that Pakistan had cruel intention behind this entire set-up.
The Kulbhushan Jadhav’s meet with his family was a trap laid down by Pakistan to force the former into confessing the crimes he did not commit. However, Kulbhushan Jadhav’s mother thwarted Pakistan’s plot.
On December 25, when Kulbhushan Jadhav’s mother and wife reached Islamabad to meet him, they were subjected to emotional and mental harassment right from the beginning. The media was allowed to fling insensitive questions at them, their religious faith was hurt in the name of “security”. But, Pakistan exhibited its coarseness when it did not allow the family to meet Kulbhushan in person and barred them from talking in their Mother Tongue-Marathi.
According to a Times of India report, Kulbhushan Jadhav greeted his mother with confessing that he was an Indian spy who worked with RAW. Strangely enough, he also confessed that he has engineered various terror plots across. However, his mother who was meeting her son after almost 21 months couldn’t believe the words coming from her son. She furiously interrupted him and asked why is he not telling the truth. She said, “Why are you telling all this? You were doing business in Iran from where you were abducted. You must tell the truth.”
The report mentioned that it was learnt from the sources that Pakistan has hatched the plot to use Jadhav’s statement as his confession. It is evident from the proofs that Kulbhushan and his family was made to sit on either sides of a glass wall. They were only allowed to communicate through intercom and in English. Jadhav’s mother after returning to India also told that it Kulbhushan was visibly under stress and the atmosphere was intimidating.
The sources also told the daily that part of Jadhav’s alleged “Confession” were handed to him by Pakistan Army and ISI. However, Jadhav’s mother interrupted which might have foiled pakistan’s plan to use the video recording of Jadhav’s statement in ICJ.
The Ministry of External Affairs still believes that Pakistan possibly play a doctored version Kulbhushan Jadhav and his mother’s conversation. But, it is also relieved by the fact that, his mother’s timely intervention may push Pakistan to do a cut-paste job.
External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj yesterday addressed the Parliament. She said, “We had suspected a notorious motive behind Pakistan retaining Jadhav’s wife’s shoe. And now, the Pakistani media channels are reporting that a metallic substance has been found in her shoe. If this is not the limit of coarseness, then what is?”
However, Pakistan’s foreign ministry brushed aside the allegations as “baseless and twisted.”
Plastic-free Maharashtra in 5 months, is it really possible?
After the deluge of 2005, the government was alarmed to the issue of plastic. But even the restrictions haven’t been able to curb the use of plastic. So while the decision to go completely plastic free is welcoming but is it really feasible for people of Maharashtra?
From a water bottle to straw, from electronics to cartons, from stationery to jars; one thing that is common in these is Plastic. There is no denying that plastic has become an integral part of our lives. Literally everything we use has some amount of plastic in it. It is the reality of today that the hazardous material is now omnipresent.
According to a study conducted in 2010-11, the amount of plastic in waste generated in Mumbai alone was 10%. In the following years it dipped to 9%. However, the use of plastic hasn’t reduced.
The Maharashtra Government has now planned to go completely plastic-free. After the deluge of 2005, the government was alarmed to the issue of plastic. But even the restrictions haven’t been able to curb the use of plastic.
So while the decision to go completely plastic free is welcoming but is it really feasible for people of Maharashtra?
We talked to environmentalist Vishal Tibrewal from My green society who has been working to spread awareness about going organic. “Going 100% plastic free is not really difficult task. We do not need to look outside to find any alternative to plastic. Instead of Plastic bottle we can use metal bottles. Rather than using plastic bags, we can use cloth bag,” Tibrewal said. He further added that people also need to participate in such steps taken by the state government and help the environment.
The state government’s effort to limit the use of plastic is not easy to enforce. In the past too, the state had tried to curb use of the plastic bags, but it did not succeed. For such a step to succeed, there ought to be a participation from the members of society. Awareness campaigns combined with penalties may help achieve the objective of reducing non-biodegradable waste
What are we turning into?
While we expect the government to be in sanity and rationally view the situation, authorities in the position have escaped themselves of the responsibility to shun these threats.
The Padmavati movie has sparked a huge debate across the country (as it is being projected). While some fringe groups want to ban the movie for the sake of it, others are either supporting them or denouncing them.
The protest which started off as a move to save the culture and history has now hit the doors of politics. Days after Karni sena member threatens to cut Deepika’s nose, another leader from Haryana Suraj Pal Amu has announced a bounty of rupees 10 crore for whoever beheads the actress and the director of the movie Sanjay Leela Bhansali.
The fringe groups have been openly threatening the actress since her remarks in which she said, “No-one can stop this movie”.
I am compelled to wonder and ponder upon the thought- are these the traits of a civilized democracy? Or we are just a democracy of hurt sentiments?
What astonishes me more is the deafening silence of the authorities. Whether there was distortion of history in Padmavati or not is a question that will be answered later when the movie releases. But isn’t government too complicit in acts such as these which taint the democratic values of the country by not taking action against the fringe?
While we expect the government to be in sanity and rationally view the situation, authorities in the position have escaped themselves of the responsibility to shun these threats. Rather vocal Information and Broadcasting Minister Smriti Irani has talked on this matter only to counter Shashi Tharoor’s ‘valorous Maharaja’ remarks. UP deputy CM Keshav Mourya, Rajasthan CM Vasundhara Raje have declared that unless the cuts are made to the film, it won’t be allowed to screen. Joining their tune is Madhya Pradesh CM Shivraj Singh.
What gives the power to the fringe to make such threat? People who are fighting for the honour of historical character of woman are threatening to behead a woman who spoke her mind out. Isn’t it an irony? The concern for a woman’s honour comes with convenience. A historical figure is more cared for than today’s woman.
It is the absurdity of the democracy when threats and graphic violent opposition is passed off as Freedom of Expression. The country which is the largest democracy of the world unfortunately fits in the narrative well.
The fringe may want to display its power by intimidating the soft targets, while the exploitative silence of the authorities continues. Which makes me wonder, what are we, the democratic people turning into?
Central government not in favour of slashing excise duty on fuel prices
Madhya Pradesh, Puducherry and 3 Northeastern states to rollout intra-State e-way bill from April 25
The fight is between forces “rejecting democracy” and voices “rescuing democracy”: Congress
Home Ministry withdraws AFSPA from Meghalaya, eight police stations in Arunachal Pradesh
“BJP se beti bachao”: Rahul Gandhi in ‘Save The Constitution’ Campaign
Why are Dalits turning away from BJP?
Pakistan PM Shahid Khaqan Abbasi allegedly stripped at US airport, Twitterati call it a ‘Karma’
Death Threat to an interfaith couple by an alleged Yogi supporter
Karnataka Assembly Elections: Polling on 12th May, Results will be declared on 15th May
Weekly Political Roundup: From Lingayat Separate religion status to BJP’s big Rajya Sabha win
Will you buy Air India?
What India opines on Justice Loya’s case
What is with BJP ministers thinking internet existed during the times of Mahabharata
Are BJP and Shiv Sena taking the Maharashtra voters for granted ?
You will be held responsible PM Modi says Former Civil Servants | Editorial with Sujit Nair
'State of Mind' by Kumar Ketkar7 days ago
Time for the liberals to unite
Karnataka Election 20187 days ago
AIADMK contesting Karnataka Elections on two seats
Karnataka Election 20187 days ago
Taxpayers’ 56 crores spent on glorifying CM Siddaramaiah – RTI
National20 hours ago
Jessica Lal’s killer “forgiven” by her sister, serving sentence in open jail
Karnataka Election 20186 days ago
Karnataka Assembly Elections buzz: Candidates start filing papers
News Report5 days ago
What is with BJP ministers thinking internet existed during the times of Mahabharata
Opinion5 days ago
National5 days ago
“I want this government to be criticized” : PM Modi in London