Opinion

Opinion | God Versus Atheism Debate is Unnecessary

The recent public exchange between Javed Akhtar and Mufti Shamail Nadwi has once again dragged us into a tired and largely meaningless binary. God versus atheism. Belief versus disbelief. As if one must defeat the other. As if society must choose a winner.

That framing itself is the problem.

Faith is not a competitive sport. Atheism is not a rebellion that needs validation. Both are deeply personal positions shaped by upbringing, experience, temperament, trauma, comfort, curiosity, or the absence of it. To argue over which is superior is to misunderstand both.

A believer does not arrive at faith through logic alone. Nor does an atheist arrive at disbelief purely through reason. These positions are not mathematical conclusions. They are existential choices. One finds meaning in surrender, the other in inquiry. One seeks answers in the divine, the other in the observable. Neither is inherently noble or inferior.

The moment belief demands submission from those who do not share it, it ceases to be spiritual and becomes political. And the moment atheism begins to mock faith rather than coexist with it, it stops being rational and becomes arrogant. Both betray their own foundations.

Civilisation did not advance because everyone believed in God. Nor did it progress because people rejected God. It moved forward when societies learned to live with difference. Science flourished alongside faith. Art was born in temples as much as in doubt. Moral behaviour existed long before organised religion, and compassion does not require divine certification.

The real divide is not between God and atheism. It is between tolerance and insecurity. Between those who can live with difference and those who cannot.

Your belief is yours. Your disbelief is yours. Neither gives you moral authority over another human being.

That argument is not just ludicrous. It is unnecessary.

A mature society does not ask people to choose sides in metaphysical debates. It asks them to choose empathy, restraint, and coexistence.

Dear Readers,
As an independent media platform, we do not take advertisements from governments and corporate houses. It is you, our readers, who have supported us on our journey to do honest and unbiased journalism. Please contribute, so that we can continue to do the same in future.

Related posts