National Opinion Politics

Opinion | Is Naya Bharat a Democracy that Cannot Question?

The voice that questions is under attack. Not because it lies. Not because it spreads hate. But because it asks uncomfortable questions.

And this is not about one political party. Question BJP and you are targeted. Question AAP and you are abused. Question Congress and you face outrage. Across the spectrum, supporters often react the same way. How dare you question our government ?

So let us ask something basic.

In a democracy, does the voice that questions not have a place? Is every citizen expected to agree with every decision taken by those in power, no matter how unreasonable it may appear? And if not agreement, then silence?

Questions by themselves are never right or wrong. They act as monitors. In isolation it means nothing. It is the answers that can be right or wrong. The moment we stop questioning, lying, deceit, immorality and corruption slowly begin to look normal. Only questions keep a check. Only questions protect people’s interest and safety

When dissent is suppressed, systems begin to decay.

When questions stop, ministers can socialise with sexual predators without scrutiny. Universities can mislead students. Agencies can conduct raids or arrests without accountability. Bad deals get signed quietly. Votes get manipulated. Innocent people get lynched. The guilty walk free. Bail is denied unfairly. Compromised appointments are made. A child sleeps hungry. A woman loses her rights.

Silencing dissent does not strengthen a nation. It weakens it.

So who really wants the questioning voice to disappear? An ordinary citizen who wants better governance? Or someone with political interests to protect?

Look closely at the aggression online. Most of the loudest attacks come from faceless profiles. No real names. No real photographs. Locked accounts.

The Rise of “Manufacturing Consent”

Over the years in digital news, one thing has become clear. A large part of this aggression is organised.

Enormous sums are spent to create distraction, to drown out facts, to intimidate those who question power. Real issues get buried under manufactured outrage. Ordinary citizens get pulled into this hostility, mistaking it for patriotism.

Let us be clear. Questioning a view is healthy. Disagreeing is healthy. Challenging facts is healthy. That is how a democracy breathes. But abuse, threats and intimidation are not debate. They are tools to create fear.

Today it is one voice being targeted. Tomorrow it could be yours. For asking why your road was not built. Why your tax money was wasted. Why your child did not get a fair exam. Why your business was targeted. Why your complaint was ignored.

Encourage questions. Encourage opinions. Encourage criticism.

Listen. Think. Use your own wisdom. Accept what makes sense. Reject what does not. But never outsource your thinking to a troll.

Dear Readers,
As an independent media platform, we do not take advertisements from governments and corporate houses. It is you, our readers, who have supported us on our journey to do honest and unbiased journalism. Please contribute, so that we can continue to do the same in future.

Related posts